This article will address the topic of Big Five (association football), a concept that has gained relevance in recent years due to its impact on various aspects of daily life. Since its emergence, Big Five (association football) has captured the attention of experts and the general public, generating debates, research and different interpretations. Over time, Big Five (association football) has become a topic of interest both in academia and in daily conversation, and its influence has spread to multiple areas, becoming a fundamental reference point for understanding current phenomena. In this review, different perspectives on Big Five (association football) will be explored, in order to provide a broad and enriching vision of its relevance and impact on contemporary society.
The Big Five refers to the association football markets of England, Germany, Spain, Italy and France. As of 2023, they are the five European leaders in size and popularity of the main domestic football leagues – the Premier League, Bundesliga, La Liga, Serie A and Ligue 1 respectively in men's football, and the Women's Super League, Frauen-Bundesliga, Liga F, Serie A, and Division 1 respectively in women's football.
In men's football, the combined resources and revenues of the Big Five domestic leagues dominate world football; according to Statista, they have a combined revenue of €15.6 billion. Within the Big Five, England's Premier League is considerably larger than the other four in terms of both popularity and wealth, with both factors influencing the other; league wealth is mostly derived from selling broadcasting rights to global markets based on the league's popularity worldwide, with competing bids. The German Bundesliga enjoys the highest average match attendance, while brand value is strongest in the main teams of Spain's La Liga, namely Real Madrid and Barcelona.
Bleacher Report noted that the Big Five all benefit from having "developed their own 'brand' of how football should be played." The website suggested that the Netherlands' top league Eredivisie was considered similarly to the Big Five in footballing terms, but did not reach the same popularity or funding levels because it is overlooked by international fans in favour of the Five.
The Big Five are seen as the collective leagues where the best players in the world go to develop and shine, and it is accepted that the Big Five "represent the pinnacle of European football". However, football fans, particularly in different regions, often debate the quality of each league compared to the others. As of 2023, the Big Five lead the UEFA coefficient for both men's and women's domestic leagues in Europe. The coefficient ranks on performance of domestic teams in European competitions; football analytics website Breaking the Lines suggested that the continued dominance of the Big Five in the coefficient for men's football relies on teams from other nations – which may be as good or better than Big Five teams when fielding their best XI – thinking there is more security in aiming for domestic titles rather than European ones, and Big Five teams having the resources available to perform in both. Women's football has been less consistently centralised and, in Europe, has also been strong in Scandinavia; as it became more popular, the largest (men's) football markets invested more, leading to a shift towards teams from the Big Five. Sweden held a spot in the UEFA coefficient instead of Italy through 2022.
In 2021, several men's teams from the Big Five leagues in England, Italy, and Spain attempted to create a European Super League, but received pushback. Teams from Germany and France were reportedly invited to join the project, but declined.
The table below show the players who have played in all Big Five Leagues.
Footballer | England | France | Germany | Italy | Spain |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Florin Răducioiu | West Ham United | Monaco | Stuttgart | Bari | Espanyol |
Brescia | |||||
Hellas Verona | |||||
Milan | |||||
Christian Poulsen | Liverpool | Evian | Schalke 04 | Juventus | Sevilla |
Stevan Jovetić | Manchester City | Monaco | Hertha BSC | Inter Milan | Sevilla |
Fiorentina | |||||
Justin Kluivert | Bournemouth | Nice | RB Leipzig | Roma | Valencia |
The table below show the winning teams in all men's Big Five leagues by season.
Season | England | Germany | Spain | Italy | France |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
1888–89 | Preston North End | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1889–90 | Preston North End | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1890–91 | Everton | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1891–92 | Sunderland | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1892–93 | Sunderland | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1893–94 | Aston Villa | --- | --- | --- | Standard Athletic Club |
1894–95 | Sunderland | --- | --- | --- | Standard Athletic Club |
1895–96 | Aston Villa | --- | --- | --- | Club Français |
1896–97 | Aston Villa | --- | --- | --- | Standard Athletic Club |
1897–98 | Sheffield United | --- | --- | Genoa | Standard Athletic Club |
1898–99 | Aston Villa | --- | --- | Genoa | Le Havre |
1899–00 | Aston Villa | --- | --- | Genoa | Le Havre |
1900–01 | Liverpool | --- | --- | Milan | Standard Athletic Club |
1901–02 | Sunderland | --- | --- | Genoa | Roubaix |
1902–03 | The Wednesday | VfB Leipzig | --- | Genoa | Roubaix |
1903–04 | The Wednesday | No champions | --- | Genoa | Roubaix |
1904–05 | Newcastle United | Union 92 Berlin | --- | Juventus | Gallia Club Paris |
1905–06 | Liverpool | VfB Leipzig | --- | Milan | Roubaix |
1906–07 | Newcastle United | Freiburger FC | --- | Milan | RC Paris |
1907–08 | Manchester United | Viktoria Berlin | --- | Pro Vercelli | Roubaix |
1908–09 | Newcastle United | Phönix Karlsruhe | --- | Pro Vercelli | Helvétique Marseille |
1909–10 | Aston Villa | Karlsruher FV | --- | Internazionale | US Tourcoing |
1910–11 | Manchester United | Viktoria Berlin | --- | Pro Vercelli | Helvétique Marseille |
1911–12 | Blackburn Rovers | Holstein Kiel | --- | Pro Vercelli | Saint-Raphaël |
1912–13 | Sunderland | VfB Leipzig | --- | Pro Vercelli | Helvétique Marseille |
1913–14 | Blackburn Rovers | SpVgg Fürth | --- | Casale | Olympique Lillois |
1914–15 | Everton | --- | --- | Genoa | --- |
1915–16 | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1916–17 | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1917–18 | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
1918–19 | --- | --- | --- | --- | Le Havre |
1919–20 | West Bromwich Albion | 1. FC Nürnberg | --- | Internazionale | --- |
1920–21 | Burnley | 1. FC Nürnberg | --- | Pro Vercelli | --- |
1921–22 | Liverpool | No champions | --- | Novese | --- |
1922–23 | Liverpool | Hamburger SV | --- | Genoa | --- |
1923–24 | Huddersfield Town | 1. FC Nürnberg | --- | Genoa | --- |
1924–25 | Huddersfield Town | 1. FC Nürnberg | --- | Bologna | --- |
1925–26 | Huddersfield Town | SpVgg Fürth | --- | Juventus | --- |
1926–27 | Newcastle United | 1. FC Nürnberg | --- | --- | CA Paris |
1927–28 | Everton | Hamburger SV | --- | Torino | Stade Français |
1928–29 | The Wednesday | SpVgg Fürth | --- | Bologna | Marseille |
1929–30 | Sheffield Wednesday | Hertha BSC | Athletic Bilbao | Ambrosiana-Inter | --- |
1930–31 | Arsenal | Hertha BSC | Athletic Bilbao | Juventus | --- |
1931–32 | Everton | Bayern Munich | Madrid FC | Juventus | --- |
1932–33 | Arsenal | Fortuna Düsseldorf | Madrid FC | Juventus | Olympique Lillois |
1933–34 | Arsenal | Schalke 04 | Athletic Bilbao | Juventus | Sète |
1934–35 | Arsenal | Schalke 04 | Real Betis | Juventus | Sochaux |
1935–36 | Sunderland | 1. FC Nürnberg | Athletic Bilbao | Bologna | RC Paris |
1936–37 | Manchester City | Schalke 04 | --- | Bologna | Marseille |
1937–38 | Arsenal | Hannover 96 | --- | Ambrosiana-Inter | Sochaux |
1938–39 | Everton | Schalke 04 | --- | Bologna | Sète |
1939–40 | --- | Schalke 04 | Atlético Aviación | Ambrosiana-Inter | --- |
1940–41 | --- | Rapid Wien | Atlético Aviación | Bologna | --- |
1941–42 | --- | Schalke 04 | Valencia | Roma | --- |
1942–43 | --- | Dresdner SC | Athletic Bilbao | Torino | --- |
1943–44 | --- | Dresdner SC | Valencia | --- | --- |
1944–45 | --- | --- | Barcelona | --- | --- |
1945–46 | --- | --- | Sevilla | Torino | Lille |
1946–47 | Liverpool | --- | Valencia | Torino | Roubaix–Tourcoing |
1947–48 | Arsenal | 1. FC Nürnberg | Barcelona | Torino | Marseille |
1948–49 | Portsmouth | VfR Mannheim | Barcelona | Torino | Reims |
1949–50 | Portsmouth | VfB Stuttgart | Atlético Madrid | Juventus | Bordeaux |
1950–51 | Tottenham Hotspur | 1. FC Kaiserslautern | Atlético Madrid | Milan | Nice |
1951–52 | Manchester United | VfB Stuttgart | Barcelona | Juventus | Nice |
1952–53 | Arsenal | 1. FC Kaiserslautern | Barcelona | Internazionale | Reims |
1953–54 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Hannover 96 | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Lille |
1954–55 | Chelsea | Rot-Weiss Essen | Real Madrid | Milan | Reims |
1955–56 | Manchester United | Borussia Dortmund | Athletic Bilbao | Fiorentina | Nice |
1956–57 | Manchester United | Borussia Dortmund | Real Madrid | Milan | Saint-Étienne |
1957–58 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Schalke 04 | Real Madrid | Juventus | Reims |
1958–59 | Wolverhampton Wanderers | Eintracht Frankfurt | Barcelona | Milan | Nice |
1959–60 | Burnley | Hamburger SV | Barcelona | Juventus | Reims |
1960–61 | Tottenham Hotspur | 1. FC Nürnberg | Real Madrid | Juventus | Monaco |
1961–62 | Ipswich Town | 1. FC Köln | Real Madrid | Milan | Reims |
1962–63 | Everton | Borussia Dortmund | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Monaco |
1963–64 | Liverpool | 1. FC Köln | Real Madrid | Bologna | Saint-Étienne |
1964–65 | Manchester United | Werder Bremen | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Nantes |
1965–66 | Liverpool | TSV 1860 Munich | Atlético Madrid | Internazionale | Nantes |
1966–67 | Manchester United | Eintracht Braunschweig | Real Madrid | Juventus | Saint-Étienne |
1967–68 | Manchester City | 1. FC Nürnberg | Real Madrid | Milan | Saint-Étienne |
1968–69 | Leeds United | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Fiorentina | Saint-Étienne |
1969–70 | Everton | Borussia Mönchengladbach | Atlético Madrid | Cagliari | Saint-Étienne |
1970–71 | Arsenal | Borussia Mönchengladbach | Valencia | Internazionale | Marseille |
1971–72 | Derby County | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Marseille |
1972–73 | Liverpool | Bayern Munich | Atlético Madrid | Juventus | Nantes |
1973–74 | Leeds United | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Lazio | Saint-Étienne |
1974–75 | Derby County | Borussia Mönchengladbach | Real Madrid | Juventus | Saint-Étienne |
1975–76 | Liverpool | Borussia Mönchengladbach | Real Madrid | Torino | Saint-Étienne |
1976–77 | Liverpool | Borussia Mönchengladbach | Atlético Madrid | Juventus | Nantes |
1977–78 | Nottingham Forest | 1. FC Köln | Real Madrid | Juventus | Monaco |
1978–79 | Liverpool | Hamburger SV | Real Madrid | Milan | Strasbourg |
1979–80 | Liverpool | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Nantes |
1980–81 | Aston Villa | Bayern Munich | Real Sociedad | Juventus | Saint-Étienne |
1981–82 | Liverpool | Hamburger SV | Real Sociedad | Juventus | Monaco |
1982–83 | Liverpool | Hamburger SV | Athletic Bilbao | Roma | Nantes |
1983–84 | Liverpool | VfB Stuttgart | Athletic Bilbao | Juventus | Bordeaux |
1984–85 | Everton | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Hellas Verona | Bordeaux |
1985–86 | Liverpool | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
1986–87 | Everton | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Napoli | Bordeaux |
1987–88 | Liverpool | Werder Bremen | Real Madrid | Milan | Monaco |
1988–89 | Arsenal | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Marseille |
1989–90 | Liverpool | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Napoli | Marseille |
1990–91 | Arsenal | 1. FC Kaiserslautern | Barcelona | Sampdoria | Marseille |
1991–92 | Leeds United | VfB Stuttgart | Barcelona | Milan | Marseille |
1992–93 | Manchester United | Werder Bremen | Barcelona | Milan | --- |
1993–94 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Milan | Paris Saint-Germain |
1994–95 | Blackburn Rovers | Borussia Dortmund | Real Madrid | Juventus | Nantes |
1995–96 | Manchester United | Borussia Dortmund | Atlético Madrid | Milan | Auxerre |
1996–97 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Monaco |
1997–98 | Arsenal | 1. FC Kaiserslautern | Barcelona | Juventus | Lens |
1998–99 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Milan | Bordeaux |
1999–00 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Deportivo La Coruña | Lazio | Monaco |
2000–01 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Roma | Nantes |
2001–02 | Arsenal | Borussia Dortmund | Valencia | Juventus | Lyon |
2002–03 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Lyon |
2003–04 | Arsenal | Werder Bremen | Valencia | Milan | Lyon |
2004–05 | Chelsea | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | --- | Lyon |
2005–06 | Chelsea | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Internazionale | Lyon |
2006–07 | Manchester United | VfB Stuttgart | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Lyon |
2007–08 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Internazionale | Lyon |
2008–09 | Manchester United | VfL Wolfsburg | Barcelona | Internazionale | Bordeaux |
2009–10 | Chelsea | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Internazionale | Marseille |
2010–11 | Manchester United | Borussia Dortmund | Barcelona | Milan | Lille |
2011–12 | Manchester City | Borussia Dortmund | Real Madrid | Juventus | Montpellier |
2012–13 | Manchester United | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2013–14 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Atlético Madrid | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2014–15 | Chelsea | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2015–16 | Leicester City | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2016–17 | Chelsea | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Monaco |
2017–18 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2018–19 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2019–20 | Liverpool | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Juventus | Paris Saint-Germain |
2020–21 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Atlético Madrid | Internazionale | Lille |
2021–22 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Real Madrid | Milan | Paris Saint-Germain |
2022–23 | Manchester City | Bayern Munich | Barcelona | Napoli | Paris Saint-Germain |
2023-24 | Bayer Leverkusen |
* Single-year seasons (mostly referring to the championship tournaments in early years) have been converted into currently-used season format.